What is the Maunder Minimum?
9 min
Level
In this article, we'll explore what the Maunder Minimum was, what caused it, how it influenced the Earth's climate, and why it still matters for scientific research today.
The voice of impact
ESG / CSR
Industries
Greenly solutions
GB
GB
How does solar activity affect climate change?
Level
The Sun is Earth’s primary source of energy, driving the planet's climate systems and making life as we know it possible. Subtle variations in solar activity, such as sunspot cycles and solar flares, have long been known to influence weather patterns and historical climate shifts. However, despite this connection, the warming the planet has experienced in recent decades cannot be attributed to solar activity alone.
Scientific data, including over 40 years of satellite observations, has shown that the Sun’s energy output has fluctuated by less than 0.1% during this period - while global temperatures have risen sharply. According to NASA and the IPCC, the warming effect from human-generated greenhouse gases is more than 270 times greater than any solar influence since the Industrial Revolution.
👉 In this article, we’ll break down how solar activity affects Earth’s climate, explain historical examples of solar-driven cooling, and explore why human emissions, not solar variations, remain the primary driver of modern climate change.
What is solar activity?
Solar activity refers to the dynamic processes occurring on the surface of the Sun that can affect the energy it emits towards Earth. These processes result from fluctuations in the Sun’s magnetic field and influence both the intensity and composition of solar radiation reaching our planet.
However, while solar activity varies over time, its direct influence on global climate patterns is limited compared to human-driven emissions.
Key aspects of solar activity:
| Term | Description |
|---|---|
| Sunspots | Dark patches on the Sun’s surface caused by intense magnetic activity. They reduce solar radiation in visible light but are often accompanied by increased emissions of ultraviolet (UV) radiation from surrounding areas, known as faculae, which slightly increase total solar output. |
| Solar Flares | Sudden bursts of energy released from the Sun’s atmosphere, often associated with sunspots. While flares can release significant energy, their influence on Earth's climate is minimal due to their short duration. |
| Coronal Mass Ejections (CMEs) | Large expulsions of plasma and magnetic fields from the Sun's corona. CMEs can disrupt Earth’s magnetic field but have limited long-term climate impact. |
| Total Solar Irradiance (TSI) | The total energy emitted by the Sun received at the top of Earth’s atmosphere. TSI fluctuates slightly during solar cycles but has remained relatively stable, with variations of less than 0.1% over recent decades. |
The solar cycle and variability:
The Sun operates on an 11-year solar cycle, during which solar activity, including sunspot numbers and TSI, naturally fluctuates. Periods of high solar activity (solar maximum) are marked by more sunspots and increased solar radiation, while periods of low activity (solar minimum) see fewer sunspots and slightly lower solar output.
Despite these fluctuations, long-term solar output has remained largely consistent, with variations too small to explain the dramatic rise in global temperatures over the past century. Scientists now widely agree that while solar activity can influence short-term weather patterns, it does not account for the ongoing warming trend seen since the mid-20th century.
Solar activity vs. greenhouse gases: Which drives climate change?
While both solar activity and greenhouse gases can influence Earth’s climate, their impacts differ significantly in both magnitude and mechanism. Modern scientific evidence overwhelmingly points to human-caused greenhouse gas emissions, not solar activity, as the primary driver of the dramatic global warming observed since the mid-20th century.
Comparing the impact: Solar forcing vs. radiative forcing
- Solar forcing: Refers to the small variations in energy output from the Sun, primarily driven by the 11-year solar cycle. Total solar irradiance (TSI) has fluctuated by less than 0.1% over the past few decades, which is insufficient to explain the current rate of global warming.
- Radiative forcing from greenhouse gases: Human activities, such as burning fossil fuels, deforestation, and industrial emissions, have significantly increased atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide (CO₂), methane (CH₄), and nitrous oxide (N₂O). These gases trap heat in the atmosphere, leading to a measurable increase in global temperatures.
Scientific evidence and global temperature trends
Scientific evidence confirms that solar activity is not responsible for modern climate change:
- Satellite data: Continuous satellite observations since the 1970s have shown minimal variation in solar output, while global temperatures have risen sharply during the same period.
- Diverging trends: Since the 1950s, solar activity has shown no net increase, while global temperatures have surged, clearly indicating that other factors - mainly greenhouse gases - are responsible.
- Climate modeling: Advanced climate models incorporating both solar activity and greenhouse gas emissions show that human-driven emissions are the dominant force behind modern warming trends.
Why greenhouse gases dominate the current warming trend
- Cumulative impact: Greenhouse gases accumulate in the atmosphere, creating a long-term warming effect. Even minor increases in CO₂ can persist for centuries, intensifying the planet’s heat retention.
- Magnitude of change: The current CO₂ concentration exceeds 420 parts per million (ppm) - the highest level in at least 800,000 years, far surpassing natural variations linked to solar activity.
- Lack of correlation: Historical temperature reconstructions show that previous climate shifts driven by solar activity were far less extreme than the current warming trend.
“ While solar variations influence Earth's climate on geological timescales, the rapid warming seen today is directly linked to human-caused greenhouse gas emissions, not fluctuations in solar activity. ”
Why is solar activity sometimes blamed for climate change?
Despite overwhelming scientific consensus, solar activity is still frequently cited as a primary driver of global warming. This misconception often stems from outdated theories, data misinterpretation, and deliberate misinformation campaigns aimed at downplaying human-caused climate change.
1. Misinterpretations of historical climate events
Certain historical climate events, like the Little Ice Age and the Medieval Warm Period, are sometimes used to suggest solar activity has a stronger influence on global temperatures than scientific evidence supports.
- The Little Ice Age (1645-1715): Often linked to the Maunder Minimum, a period of exceptionally low sunspot activity. However, modern research indicates this cooling was primarily driven by volcanic eruptions and ocean circulation changes, with solar activity playing only a minor role.
- The Medieval Warm Period (950-1250 CE): While sometimes attributed to increased solar activity, this period's warming was largely regional, not global, and cannot be directly compared to today's widespread temperature rise.
2. Cherry-picking short-term data
Some arguments blaming solar activity for climate change rely on short-term correlations between solar cycles and temperature fluctuations, ignoring the broader trends.
- Solar cycle influence: The Sun’s natural 11-year cycle results in minor fluctuations in solar energy, but these variations are too small to drive significant global temperature changes.
- Selective use of data: Misinformation often highlights brief cooling periods, like those observed during solar minima, while ignoring the long-term warming trend driven by rising greenhouse gas levels.
3. Misinformation and scientific distortion
Several misinformation campaigns have intentionally exaggerated the role of solar activity while downplaying human impact.
- Simplified graphs: Some graphs misleadingly compare solar output and temperature changes without accounting for the much larger influence of greenhouse gases.
- Outdated theories: The cosmic ray-cloud hypothesis, which suggested solar activity influences cloud cover and therefore climate, has been largely discredited due to a lack of scientific support.
4. The role of scientific uncertainty
While there are minor uncertainties in how solar activity interacts with Earth’s atmosphere, these gaps are often exploited to cast doubt on climate science as a whole.
- Lack of significant trends: Modern climate models that include solar activity show it has a minimal influence compared to greenhouse gas forcing.
- Exaggeration of uncertainty: Genuine scientific uncertainty about secondary solar-climate interactions (like regional weather patterns) does not undermine the overwhelming evidence of human-driven warming.
Close
How do scientists measure solar activity’s effect on climate?
To understand the relationship between solar activity and climate change, scientists rely on precise measurements and historical data that capture fluctuations in solar output over time. These methods allow researchers to differentiate between natural variations driven by solar cycles and the overwhelming impact of greenhouse gas emissions on modern climate trends.
1. Total Solar Irradiance (TSI) measurements
Total Solar Irradiance (TSI) represents the total amount of solar energy reaching Earth’s upper atmosphere. Measuring TSI provides a direct way to assess how much energy the Sun contributes to Earth's climate system.
- Satellite observations: Since the late 1970s, satellites have continuously monitored TSI, showing minimal fluctuations of less than 0.1% over solar cycles. These small variations are insufficient to explain the dramatic temperature rise observed since the mid-20th century.
- Historical TSI reconstructions: For periods before satellite measurements, scientists reconstruct TSI using indirect data sources like sunspot records and isotopic analysis.
2. Sunspot records and solar cycles
Sunspots (dark, temporary spots on the Sun’s surface caused by magnetic activity) are directly linked to solar output and can be used as proxies for solar activity over long periods.
- Sunspot counting: Sunspot observations, dating back to the early 1600s, help scientists track solar cycles and periods of heightened or reduced solar activity.
- Maunder minimum: This historical period of very low sunspot activity (1645-1715) coincided with a slight global cooling during the Little Ice Age, though volcanic activity and ocean circulation played a larger role.
3. Cosmic ray and isotope data (Paleoclimate Proxies)
Cosmic rays and certain isotopes offer further insights into solar activity long before modern observational tools were available.
- Cosmic rays and cloud formation: The hypothesis that cosmic rays influence cloud cover (and therefore climate) has been largely discredited due to insufficient evidence of significant climate impact.
- Isotope analysis: Beryllium-10 and Carbon-14 isotopes, preserved in ice cores and tree rings, reveal past fluctuations in solar activity and its minimal role in historical climate shifts.
4. Climate models incorporating solar variability
Modern climate models incorporate both solar activity and greenhouse gas emissions to simulate climate patterns and identify key drivers of global temperature changes.
- Model comparisons: Models including only solar variability fail to replicate the current warming trend, while models incorporating greenhouse gases closely match observed temperature increases.
- Attribution studies: Studies using climate models repeatedly show that greenhouse gas forcing has dominated since the mid-20th century, far outweighing any influence from solar variations.
💡By using a combination of satellite measurements, paleoclimate data, and advanced climate models, scientists have demonstrated that solar activity plays a minor role in modern climate change compared to human-caused emissions.
The scientific consensus: Solar activity’s limited role in modern warming
The overwhelming scientific consensus is clear: while solar activity has a small influence on Earth’s climate, it is not responsible for the rapid global warming observed in recent decades. Extensive research from leading scientific bodies, including NASA, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), and the Grantham Institute, consistently confirms that human-caused greenhouse gas emissions are the dominant driver of modern climate change.
Close
How Greenly can help your company
Greenly offers expert carbon management solutions designed to help businesses effectively measure, reduce, and report their emissions.
- Comprehensive emissions tracking: Greenly’s platform monitors Scope 1, 2, and 3 emissions, providing a complete overview of your company’s carbon footprint.
- Tailored reduction strategies: Greenly helps create customised action plans and data insights to help businesses set and achieve long-term emissions reduction goals.
- Supply chain sustainability: The platform supports businesses in identifying sustainable suppliers and minimising emissions across their supply chain.
- Science-based targets support: Greenly assists companies in aligning with science-based targets through accurate data analysis and progress reporting.
By partnering with Greenly, businesses can take meaningful steps towards sustainability, ensuring regulatory compliance while enhancing their brand's environmental responsibility. Get in touch today to find out more.
Sources
- NASA, What Is the Sun’s Role in Climate Change?, https://science.nasa.gov/earth/climate-change/what-is-the-suns-role-in-climate-change/
- World Meteorological Organization, Greenhouse gas concentrations surge again to new record in 2023, https://wmo.int/media/news/greenhouse-gas-concentrations-surge-again-new-record-2023#:~:text=The%20globally%2Daveraged%20surface%20concentration,1750)%20levels%2C%20it%20said.
- Imperial College London, Solar influences on climate, https://www.imperial.ac.uk/media/imperial-college/grantham-institute/public/publications/briefing-papers/Solar-Influences-on-Climate---Grantham-BP-5.pdf
More articles
View all
What Should We Learn from the Los Angeles Wildfires?
9 min
Level
In this article, we’ll explain how the wildfires in L.A. started, how they impact society, and how the city of Los Angeles can move forward.
How to Solve Global Warming: Challenges & Solutions
12 min
Level
In this article, we’ll break down what global warming is, the key factors driving it, and the most effective solutions to mitigate its impact.
What is the Air Quality Index?
10 min
Level
What is the air quality index, how does it work, why is it important in today’s society as climate change progresses, and how can air quality index be improved?
Share
Subscribe to the newsletter