What is cloud seeding (or artificial rain)?

Cloud seeding, a method designed to generate rain or snow artificially - often termed artificial rain - has sparked interest and debate since its inception some decades ago. This article explores the science behind cloud seeding, its various methods, global applications, and the ongoing debate over its effectiveness and environmental impact, especially in the context of climate change. As this practice becomes more common worldwide, understanding its benefits and risks is crucial for future environmental strategies.

👉 What is cloud seeding? How does it work? Are there any potential risks involved? Can artificial rain be deployed as an effective tool in the fight against climate change?

Artificial rain, also known as cloud seeding is what’s known as a weather modification technique. It artificially alters the weather by enhancing the ability of clouds to produce so-called “artificial rain” or snow, which can help meet the precipitation needs of a particular region. 

The technique might sound like something from a science fiction movie but the idea can actually be dated back to World War II and it’s currently being practised in many regions across the world. 

Yet, despite the fact that cloud seeding is now commonplace it has a somewhat controversial history, with concerns raised around its effectiveness and potential to cause harm. As the fight against climate change heats up, the practice is increasingly coming under scrutiny and the question is raised: is cloud seeding an effective weapon against global warming, or does it actually cause more harm than good? 

Cloud seeding creates artificial rain by injecting substances such as silver iodide, potassium iodide, dry ice (solid carbon dioxide), liquid propane, or salt into clouds in order to induce precipitation. By dispersing these substances the microphysical processes within the cloud are altered and precipitation is improved. 

Clouds are composed of tiny water droplets or ice crystals that form when water vapour in our atmosphere cools and condenses around a particle of dust or salt floating in the air. Cloud seeding stimulates this process by introducing particles that act as ice nuclei, allowing ice crystals to form, which when heavy enough fall to Earth as rain or snow. 

The effects of cloud seeding depend on the conditions of the cloud into which the substance is introduced. For example, snowfall can be induced instead of rain when a substance such as silver iodide is introduced into subfreezing clouds (clouds with temperatures of between -20 and -7 degrees Celsius). The substance acts as an ice nucleus and allows snowflakes to form around it.

The process of releasing seeding substances is accomplished using either ground-based dispersion mechanisms, such as generators or canisters launched from anti-aircraft guns or rockets, or through aerial deployment from aircraft.

There are three main cloud seeding methods used today: 

• Static cloud seeding - Static cloud seeding involves the release of a chemical such as silver iodide into clouds. The silver iodide (or alternative substance) provides a crystal around which moisture is able to condense. This moisture is already present in the clouds, but the silver iodide makes the clouds much more effective at dispensing their water. 
• Dynamic cloud seeding - Dynamic cloud seeding works by supporting vertical air currents, which in turn allows more moisture to pass through the clouds, thereby leading to more rain. The process is more complex than static cloud seeding and it requires larger volumes of seeding material. 
• Hygroscopic cloud seeding - Hygroscopic cloud seeding involves the dispersal of salts through flares of explosives into the lower section of the clouds. It speeds up droplet coalescence leading to the formation of large droplets that lead to precipitation. 

Cloud seeding has been adopted by a number of countries around the world for a variety of different reasons: for example to increase water supply, enhance rain for agriculture, reduce hail damage, or even to disperse fog. Some of the most notable examples include: 

The US

In the United States, cloud seeding has been practised for decades, especially in states like California, Texas, and Colorado. These states often face water scarcity issues, and cloud seeding offers a potential solution to enhance rainfall and snowpack. In California, for instance, cloud seeding projects are implemented in various watersheds to increase the water supply in reservoirs. 

Middle East

Similarly, in the Middle East, countries like the United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia have turned to cloud seeding to address their arid conditions. The UAE, in particular, has invested heavily in cloud seeding research and operations as part of its quest to secure water resources in its desert climate.

China

In Asia, China has one of the world’s largest cloud seeding systems, which was prominently used during the 2008 Beijing Olympics to reduce air pollution and ensure pleasant weather conditions. The country continues to expand its weather modification programs, aiming to cover an area greater than the size of India by 2025.

Australia

Australia has also experimented with cloud seeding, especially in the states of Tasmania and New South Wales, to enhance rainfall for hydroelectric power generation and agricultural purposes. 

Europe

In Europe, countries like France and Spain have undertaken cloud seeding projects, often focusing on increasing precipitation in mountainous regions to boost water reserves and support ski resorts.

💡 This widespread adoption of cloud seeding reflects a growing interest in weather modification as a tool to mitigate water scarcity and support agriculture. However, it's important to note that the effectiveness and environmental impacts of cloud seeding continue to be topics of debate among scientists and environmentalists. Despite its increasing use, there remains a need for more comprehensive research to fully understand the implications of cloud seeding in different climatic conditions.

👉 Find out more about the harmful impacts of heatwaves and drought over on our blog. 

The debate around the safety and efficacy of cloud seeding encompasses a number of issues including environmental, ethical, and meteorological concerns. Despite its growing popularity as a method to enhance rainfall, cloud seeding has attracted scrutiny for its potential environmental impact and the broader implications of artificially altering weather patterns.

Environmental concerns

One of the main concerns with cloud seeding is its potential environmental impact. The use of chemicals like silver iodide raises questions about the long-term effects on ecosystems. While silver iodide is considered relatively low in toxicity, its accumulation in the environment and possible effects on wildlife and water quality are areas of ongoing research. 

Moreover, the injection of other substances like dry ice or salt into the atmosphere could also have unforeseen ecological consequences which is why thorough and continuous environmental monitoring is necessary to determine the impact of these substances on the environment.

Meteorological implications

Another critical aspect of the debate is the meteorological effects of cloud seeding. There are concerns that altering precipitation patterns in one area could inadvertently affect weather systems in another, leading to unforeseen changes in local climates. These unintended consequences could potentially disrupt natural weather cycles, impacting agriculture and ecosystems in regions beyond the targeted area.

Ethical and legal considerations

The ethical and legal dimensions of cloud seeding also contribute to its controversy. The idea of manipulating weather raises questions about ownership and control of natural resources. There are potential conflicts over water rights and concerns about the equity of water distribution, particularly in regions where water scarcity is a pressing issue. Furthermore, the potential for cross-border impacts of cloud seeding operations poses challenges in international law and diplomacy.

Effectiveness and efficiency

Questions also linger over the effectiveness and efficiency of cloud seeding. While there have been successful cases of increased precipitation, the overall reliability and predictability of these outcomes remain uncertain. The variability in cloud conditions and the complexity of atmospheric processes make it difficult to standardise and consistently replicate successful cloud seeding operations.

What happened

Recently, Dubai experienced unprecedented flooding due to an intense storm that delivered over a year’s worth of rainfall in just a few hours. This extreme weather event caused significant disruptions, flooded streets, and affected daily life across the city. 

❗️Dubai recorded a record rainfall of 256mm within 24 hours. The annual average rainfall is 97mm!

The claims about cloud seeding

Following the floods, there was speculation on social media that cloud seeding was responsible for the extreme rainfall. The UAE has historically used cloud seeding to mitigate water scarcity. Reports indicated that cloud seeding operations were conducted in the days leading up to the flooding, adding fuel to these speculations.

Debunking the claims

Experts and meteorological data quickly dispelled the notion that cloud seeding caused the flooding. Meteorologists clarified that cloud seeding cannot generate rain from clear skies - it can only enhance precipitation from existing clouds. Furthermore, the weather pattern responsible for the downpour was a natural meteorological event. This weather system at play was so significant that cloud seeding operations would have had a negligible effect on the outcome.

Climate change as a contributor

Climate scientists think that climate change is a more likely explanation for the severity of the rainfall. Warmer air holds more moisture - approximately 7% more for every degree Celsius increase - and is likely to have contributed to the intensity of the rainfall. Research suggests that the UAE could see up to a 30% increase in annual rainfall by the century’s end if global temperatures continue to rise, exacerbating such extreme weather events.

As the debate around cloud seeding continues, its potential role in climate change mitigation and adaptation strategies becomes a focal point of discussion. This section aims to explore how cloud seeding could be integrated into broader climate change efforts, considering both the opportunities it presents and the challenges it faces.

Opportunities for cloud seeding in climate change mitigation

• Enhancing water security - In the face of climate change-induced droughts, cloud seeding offers a method to potentially enhance water availability, particularly in arid and semi-arid regions. By increasing precipitation, it could play a role in securing water for agriculture, drinking, and other essential uses.
• Cooling urban heat - In urban areas, where the “heat island effect” exacerbates temperature extremes, cloud seeding could be employed to trigger cooling rainfall, thereby reducing the demand for energy-intensive air conditioning and contributing to urban climate resilience.
• Supporting ecosystem health - By potentially increasing precipitation in drought-affected ecosystems, cloud seeding could aid in the preservation of biodiversity, offering relief to stressed natural habitats and contributing to the overall health of ecosystems.

Challenges in leveraging cloud seeding for climate change

• Predictability and control - The inherent unpredictability of weather systems makes it challenging to control and predict the outcomes of cloud seeding accurately, raising questions about its reliability as a climate change adaptation tool.
• Scaling and scope - Scaling cloud seeding operations to a level where they can have a significant impact on climate change poses logistical and technological challenges. The localised nature of cloud seeding also limits its scope in addressing the global scale of climate change.
• Monitoring and measurement - Effective integration of cloud seeding into climate change strategies requires robust systems for monitoring and measuring its impacts, both environmentally and meteorologically. Developing these systems is essential to ensure responsible and effective use of the technology.

The path forward: research, collaboration, and governance

• Continued research and development - Advancing our understanding of the interactions between cloud seeding, weather patterns, and climate systems is crucial. Ongoing scientific research will be vital in evaluating the potential and limitations of cloud seeding as part of climate change strategies.
• International collaboration - Given the cross-border nature of weather systems, international collaboration is necessary to develop guidelines and share best practices for cloud seeding operations, ensuring that they are conducted responsibly and do not negatively impact neighbouring regions.
• Regulatory frameworks and governance - Establishing clear regulatory frameworks and governance mechanisms is essential to address the ethical, legal, and environmental concerns associated with cloud seeding. These frameworks should balance the drive for innovation with the need to protect ecosystems and communities.

👉 Learn more about the impacts of climate change in our article. 

At Greenly we can help you to assess your company’s carbon footprint, and then give you the tools you need to cut down on emissions. Why not request a free demo with one of our experts - no obligation or commitment required. 

If reading this article has inspired you to consider your company’s own carbon footprint, Greenly can help. Learn more about Greenly’s carbon management platform here.